Back to Week 71 Ethics Headlines
Britain's oldest mother-to-be appeals for privacy

ctv.ca.com
May 3, 2006

A 63-year-old child psychiatrist who is set to become Britain's oldest mother sought to defend her decision against accusations of selfishness on Thursday, saying she takes her responsibility as a parent seriously.
"We're delighted with the pregnancy," Patricia Rashbrook, who is seven months pregnant, told reporters Thursday.
"We take our responsibility very seriously and regard the best interest of the child as paramount. What we would wish now is the right to pursue our family life in private."
When asked whether she was too old to have a child, she replied: "No comment."
Earlier, Rashbrook and her husband John Farrant, 61, issued a joint statement, saying: "We wish to emphasize that this has not been an endeavour undertaken lightly or without courage."
"A great deal of thought has been given to planning and providing for the child's present and future wellbeing, medically, socially and materially."
Controversial Italian fertility doctor, Severino Antinori, said he only treated Rashbrook in an unnamed former Soviet republic after she underwent strict medical examinations.
Antinori has told reporters that she and her husband first visited him three years ago at his clinic in Rome, where he specializes in treating older women.
Details are sketchy but it's believed that Rashbrook, who is from Lewes, East Sussex, was given the treatment last October and it was successful at the first attempt, using a single embryo.
Antinori told Reuters that Rashbrook was "perfect" for the treatment, because although she was 62 at the time, she had a biological age of about 45.
Antinori said age 62 or 63 was the maximum age for in vitro fertilization in healthy women.
He dismissed criticism that Rashbrook was too old to become a parent, telling the wire agency: "She should live for at least 20 to 25 years -- we are not giving birth to an orphan."
Antinori gained notoriety in 1994 when he helped a post-menopausal Italian woman in her early 60s give birth following fertility treatment with a donated egg.
He has said in the past he aimed to be the first to produce a baby cloned from an adult.
In 1997, Welsh woman Liz Buttle became Britain's oldest mother at the age of 60.
The oldest woman in the world to become a mother is believed to be 66-year-old Romanian Adriana Iliescu, who gave birth to a daughter last year after IVF treatment.
Rashbrook's pregnancy has sparked criticism from some groups.
Josephine Quintavalle, from the London-based Comment on Reproductive Ethics, said: "It is extremely difficult for a child to have a mother who is as old as a grandmother would be. "It is just that consumer society that wants absolutely everything, and never stops to think that a child is not a product. She is being selfish and sometimes greater love is saying no."
Campaign group Life also warned that Rashbrook's pregnancy was not in the best interests of the child.
"We see this just as another component in our culture where children are treated as a means to an end," said spokesman Matthew O'Gorman said.
"Quite simply, the child is not being looked after properly - one is not genuinely having regard for the welfare of the child.
"He or she is going to be without a mother or father at the most crucial moment of adolescence or when that child is growing to maturity. This is not the way to bring a child into the world."



© Copyright 2002-2006 Bell Globemedia Inc.

Back to Week 71 Ethics Headlines